Question of Aqa e … from Head office of Al-Monji

In the Other Dua Ahad it has been mentioned “«وبإسحاق الذي جعل الله النبوّة في ذريّته»”. Is every Dua and Ziyarat, which encloses the prophet hood within the progeny of prophet Ishaaq is unauthentic and have an Israeli background?
Is every Dua that mention about the progeny of the Prophet Ishaaq is unauthentic and have an Israeli background?

Answer:
Firstly: Our great scholars such as deceased Syed bin Ta’oos, Allama Majlisi  have mentioned the “Other Dua e Ahad” and even we have mentioned it in our book “Sahefa e MAhadiyah”. However the above-mentioned quotation is neither present in our book “Sahifa e MAhadiyah” nor in the books of the above mentioned scholars.

Secondly: the above-mentioned quotation does not encloses the prophet hood in the progeny of Prophet Ishaaq.

Thirdly: It only state that the prophet hood shall be in the progeny of Prophet Ishaaq however, it does not discard the Prophet Hood of others.

Fourthly: If each Dua or Surah, which only mentions Prophet Ishaaq, is unauthentic. In that case, Surah Ankaboot “The Spider” should also be Unauthentic because in the ayah 27 of the same Surah it is also stated “«ووهبنا له اسحاق ويعقوب وجعلنا في ذريّته النبوّة  ...»” that we have continued the Prophet Hood in the progeny of Ishaaq that is Yaqoob and his descendant, identical to the quotation of the mentioned Dua.
Those who give their views should think over their views before expressing it, so that it does not harm them in the mere future.